Time Nick Message 10:07 [MatrxMT] Given our AI policy, do we want to feature something like this? https://github.com/LibreSprite/LibreSprite/blob/master/AGENTS.md 10:08 [MatrxMT] (I only use AI for spodadic audits so I genuinely don't know if it can be useful) 10:09 [MatrxMT] *sporadic 17:07 SFENCE sfan5: I usally inform here, that macos binaries were added. https://irc.luanti.org/luanti-dev/2026-11-01#i_6349281 17:07 SFENCE sfan5: should I mention you or somebody else next time? 17:07 sfan5 no it's fine 17:11 Krock waaaah merge conflicts are so annoyung 18:06 MTDiscord Have you tried rebooting your computer yet? :P 19:40 andriyndev https://github.com/luanti-org/luanti/blob/master/doc/developing/ai_policy.md. It’d be great to add the definition of “vibe coding”, because different people interpret it differently. 19:42 sfan5 vibe coding is letting the AI write code without oversight or review, isn't it? 19:45 Krock and a "work harder" prompt is probably not counted as oversight 19:46 Krock (not implying that it happened here, just nonsense remark) 19:47 celeron55 i stumbled upon this proposal for the grading of AI use. i think it's pretty good: https://www.bennjordan.com/blog/we-should-standardize-vibe-coding-ethics 19:47 Krock defining rules is difficult and they may be enforced differently on a case basis 19:51 Krock our policy seems to best fit into the "AI-dev-A" category ^ 19:51 celeron55 in the case of the luanti core, out of those, the maximum allowable is probably AI-dev-A, and AI-UI, while considered lesser in that list, only applies as a mitigation in some specific cases 19:51 MTDiscord That article already fails in the first few lines by assuming there is no valid problems to be solved by the other generative content 19:52 celeron55 feel free to write a better article. i'll then cite that instead going forward 19:52 celeron55 it's close enough to reality in order to be useful 19:53 MTDiscord The AI-UI definition is also rather arbitrary, why is an AI-written interface important? 19:53 Krock I assume this distinction was made because UI appears to be easier to test/verify (already by looking at it) 19:53 celeron55 i think the main implication there is that in the case of AI-UI, all of the API and persistence related things were reviewed by an experienced developer. I'd redefine it as AI-ephemeral or something like that 19:54 celeron55 or AI-frontend 19:55 MTDiscord "AI music solves the imaginary problem of there not being enough music on Spotify." Is so blind to humanity it makes me wonder if this was written by AI. It obviously solves the problem of people wanting to be able to express themselves with music, but not having the time or skill set to be able to compose it from scratch themselves. It doesn't have to be professional level or end up on spotify. 19:56 celeron55 you can definitely grade AI assistance in music making very similarly 19:56 celeron55 and anything else too 19:56 MTDiscord I certainly plan to write my own article about this at some point, but it is certainly not prerequisite to understanding that the article is not standing on good foundations. 19:57 MTDiscord Just because it fits your paradigm decently does not make it a good reference 19:57 celeron55 it's basically "did you prompt it to do something specific (more points if you fed in some of your own material), and did you review the end result thoroughly" 19:57 MTDiscord Your own summary of the system is better than the system itself 19:59 MTDiscord I'm hoping the vibe situation with AI is temporary. Imagine if we had modern compilers but we still checked in the .asm they generated instead of the actual source, after manual review, because they occasionally generated code with subtle errors. It would be a nightmare. 20:00 MTDiscord Hopefully, what is currently vibe coding will become a higher-level description language. 20:01 celeron55 i predict during the next decade people will start calling human-made things slop, as AI will be perfect on a level which simply doesn't invoke the feel of slop at all and humans are the ones being sloppy. which basically results in a world where everything polished is made by AI and if you want something made manually by a human, you have to look for something very "punk" 20:02 ZenonSeth etsy but for devs 20:03 celeron55 most people don't care about creator ethics on a level where they'd be angry of AI use if the result is better than otherwise. It's very similar as the current situation in software ethics - only the FOSS community cares about the details, everyone else just consumes regardless of how it was made 20:04 celeron55 similar to* (AI wouldn't have made that mistake) 20:04 ZenonSeth for the specific PR that andriyndev, who seems to have joined just to post that 1 message and left mentioned - that PR was 5k lines and growing. Even if it was reviewed by hand, that's irresponsible use of llms - pile on code and more code and more changes without feedback 20:05 MTDiscord Agreed, but that is not unique to LLMs. That is irresponsible development in general, and rules should not discriminate the tools used 20:11 MTDiscord I think it's an interesting idea to use LLMs for prototyping larger features, expecting that there's a high chance you'll just end up throwing the code away. I don't think that's really problematic per se. 20:11 ZenonSeth personally I think subjective application of the rules is going to be the best people can do for a while, because to me LLM usage right now falls under sorites paradox - you can tell the really bad cases from the really good ones, but there's plenty inbetween that are subjective 20:12 ZenonSeth luatic: For what purpose? did you spend a good half hour reading the code changes? is it worth it if they'll be thrown away? prototyping locally sure, but PR? 20:13 MTDiscord ZenonSeth: wasn't the PR marked as draft? 20:15 ZenonSeth sure, yes, but it was still a public PR that was normally unreviewable, unless the details had previously been discussed a lot 20:15 MTDiscord Personally I don't really mind sloppy code (yes, even of the AI kind) in drafts, I'll just take a peek and if I don't find it interesting, spend my time elsewhere. Often I'll also just ignore drafts. 20:15 [MatrxMT] for a website or something, ai-ui is an important distinction 20:15 ZenonSeth eh fair 20:16 ZenonSeth (in reply to luatic) 20:16 [MatrxMT] for luanti, not so much (i guess the only real "ui" stuff is in the settings and main menu) 20:16 [MatrxMT] my 2 cents 20:16 [MatrxMT] (ish?) 20:20 celeron55 i agree with luatic: it's perfectly ok to use an LLM to make a proof of concept to find out if something is possible, and also to post it as a draft PR for people to look at and see that if such a feature is desired, the cost is probably N lines touching the code the draft does touch. the disagreement here seems to be mostly whether there's any expectation of anyone reacting to it in any other way 20:20 celeron55 than saying "that's a lot of lines, not worth it, i'll pass" or ignoring it entirely 20:23 ZenonSeth yea i think the trigger was that the pr was closed today with comment linking to ai-policy. And as i said that i got an email of more comments on the pr so it ain't over yet 20:24 celeron55 i'd say responding "write it without AI and come back, and then i'll look at it" is not necessarily fair, because it is functional code and as such, anything a human does probably can't squeeze it into half the lines or half the dependencies or anything like that. asking someone to spend effort on something that won't be accepted anyway isn't fair, if they already provided the proof of concept which 20:24 celeron55 already contains the important aspects 20:26 celeron55 i'd say in general if someone posts a draft PR, the way forward from that is a concept review (either a full one, or one which weighs the scope vs. the roadmap), and if the concept is approved, then it is fair to ask for a version with significantly more oversight and optimization 20:26 celeron55 if it's not approved, then it's best to be clear about it: no amount of manual coding will make it acceptable 20:27 celeron55 (unless, of course, it's changed to an extent which completely alters the lines-of-code or dependency requirements, or whatever) 20:29 celeron55 i'm not sure if i'm making my point understandable at all :D i'm trying to say there's value in a proof of concept, regardless of how it's made, and it's wise to utilize that value, and to utilize that value doesn't mean merging the PR 22:20 [MatrxMT] I don't understand how the new version is cleaner than the old one 22:20 [MatrxMT] https://i.imgur.com/ofWtGJF.png 22:20 [MatrxMT] it feels very redundant 22:41 rubenwardy ah yes, "Content not available in your region" 22:42 [MatrxMT] I'd link GitLab but it keeps me out because it says that I've reached the rate limit. By opening 5 pages and not using webhooks, AI or anything :))) 22:48 [MatrxMT] RE AI: it seems to me that nobody would look at a 5k PoC anyway, no matter if it's AI or not, so I can't see the problem (nor the reason to discuss it further) 22:50 [MatrxMT] Also, call me romantic of whatever, but I think we should build community, helping people getting better at their skills by providing insightful reviews. It's an investment for the future. On the contrary, 22:51 [MatrxMT] what's the purpose of reviewing code made by a machine? I mean, there's no investment, no community building 22:52 MTDiscord If an active member of the community finds something they want to fix, but has no coding skills, I see no reason to require them to learn programming just to fix it. They are invested, and are part of the community. The purpose is to ensure someone knowledgeable has verified it works and looks ok. 22:52 [MatrxMT] Let alone all the ethical issues that we're ignoring right away - something I find absurd 22:53 [MatrxMT] That is slop, green. No coding skills, just prompted and fingers crossed 22:53 [MatrxMT] so more work for maintainers 22:54 MTDiscord How much do they need to know for it to not be slop? 22:55 rubenwardy ~~it's less about the knowledge and more about the expensive student loans~~ 22:59 MTDiscord Im playing the extreme end of the scale here to say the rules dont adequately account for all cases. I dont think blind vibecoding is helpful most of the time. I think distinguishing the tool is incorrect. "Can you take responsibility for this code or not?" 23:09 [MatrxMT] I think that that is a slippery slope 23:11 MTDiscord And I think it is a slippery slope to ban AI or demand disclosure for any use of it 23:11 MTDiscord I should really write about this, I tire of explaining this frequently 23:15 MTDiscord are we taking bets on that? 23:16 MTDiscord Zughy: re the screenshot you've shared above, looks reasonable, depending on what you want. if that code is supposed to hide a nametag by making it transparent - and nothing else - then what the change does (preserve current RGB) makes sense. 23:17 MTDiscord it fixes a minor bug where the color would otherwise be lost (the C++ reading code always replaces the entire color, not just a single component). 23:18 MTDiscord github is getting on my nerves with a banner pestering me to add payment info, even though i only use their free stuff 😒 23:18 MTDiscord got a picture? i think all the banners ive ever seen ive closed and they went away 23:32 [MatrxMT] luatic: yes but now I have explicitly state that r, g and b are equal to what they used to be 23:32 [MatrxMT] *have to 23:33 [MatrxMT] I understand it for e.g. HUD's alignment, but colour of nametag, c'mon.. 23:34 [MatrxMT] I don't expect the game to crash if I only declare the sun table instead od stars, moon etc. in set_sky(). Same logic 23:34 [MatrxMT] *or 23:43 MTDiscord Zughy: ah, you're complaining about the engine warning? i think that's useful actually. 23:44 MTDiscord because you're replacing the color wholesale, and if you're forced to specify the entire color that becomes obvious. (under the hood, the engine is reading a "colorspec".) 23:44 MTDiscord it's not "incremental" in the way set_properties() is. 23:44 MTDiscord what your previous code was doing was equivalent not to setting just a = 0, but rather to setting the entire color to {r = 0, g = 0, b = 0, a = 0}.