Luanti logo

IRC log for #luanti, 2026-10-23

| Channels | #luanti index | Today | | Google Search | Plaintext

All times shown according to UTC.

Time Nick Message
00:00 bgstack15 Ah. Hm, while I'm not a huge fan of formspec, I do have a number of them that I've written, so it could be some work to convert them.
00:00 * technomancy hears the words "replacing formspec" and immediately gains 10 morale points
00:01 Helenah technomancy: It is a plan. :)
00:01 technomancy formspecs are the worst part of learning to write mods by a huuuuuge margin
00:01 technomancy godspeed
00:02 Helenah bgstack15: I bet these days, an LLM could do the conversion for you, and you then just go over the conversion output, test, make sure is fine, and if not quite fine, clean it up.
00:02 technomancy surely a normal compiler could do that
00:02 user333_ formspec replacement is easy, just bundle chromiu-
00:02 technomancy why deprive honest programmers of an excuse to write a compiler. seems cruel.
00:03 * bgstack15 slaps user333_
00:03 * user333_ bonks bgstack15
00:03 Helenah technomancy: Then do that.
00:03 technomancy very tempted
00:03 Helenah Do it then. :)
00:03 Helenah rofl
00:04 technomancy is there a write-up on the replacement?
00:04 bgstack15 I don't mind formspec. In some ways it's nice to just slap some extra things on the end, because coordinates are per-element so you can still insert something near the top of a formspec, even though it's at the end of a formspec string/table.
00:05 Helenah https://github.com/luanti-org/luanti/issues/6527    https://github.com/luanti-org/luanti/issues/1399
00:05 technomancy lol at the first line: "Please don't suggest HTML/CSS, as this has already been decided against"
00:06 user333_ without a heavy backend like chromium, html+css would be mostly fine tbh
00:06 user333_ just not javascript >:(
00:07 Helenah It's more re-design discussions though.
00:07 technomancy idk HTML is a syntax for writing tree structured data but we already have a perfectly good syntax for writing tree structured data called "Lua"
00:08 Helenah I think Luanti will also eventually swallow into itself IrrlichtMT.
00:10 user333_ HTML within a string in lua is my idea, it also means you can apply (some) web dev knowledge to making GUIs
00:13 illwieckz joined #luanti
00:15 user333_ unfortunately unless an extremely lightweight html + css renderer exists, that's not really doable
00:15 [MatrxMT]_ <Blockhead256> it's all lightweight if you take out 25 years of features
00:16 user333_ unfortunately that takes out 25 years of features
00:17 [MatrxMT]_ <Blockhead256> you don't need most of those though. Actually, formspec's existing markup is "good enough" most of the time
00:18 [MatrxMT]_ <Blockhead256> Think about Facebook vs MySpace. You could do any old HTML+CSS on MySpace. Facebook gives you *very* few options. Most of is  the built-in styling decisions done by facebook. Same goes for the pre-decided formspec styling in a game for Luanti
00:18 user333_ true
00:19 user333_ though porting an old browser engine to modern c++ and integrating it into the engine would be more work than it's worth
00:27 kimapr left #luanti
00:27 technomancy not to mention the mountain of security vulnerabilities you would bring along with it
00:27 user333_ magically fixing all of those would be part of porting it to modern c++
00:30 Montresor joined #luanti
00:32 technomancy lol, good thinking
00:32 * technomancy taps forehead
00:35 silverwolf73828 joined #luanti
00:47 illwieckz joined #luanti
01:25 illwieckz joined #luanti
02:05 Sheriff_U3 This is not a good sign from flint... `634 errors, 372 warnings in 43 files error: lint found 634 errors`
02:16 chilledfrogs joined #luanti
03:02 Alias joined #luanti
04:00 MTDiscord joined #luanti
04:01 AliasStillTaken joined #luanti
04:06 MTDiscord <sheriff_u3> It's sad to see that Debian testing and unstable are still stuck with Luanti v5.15.2 with Debian stable having v5.10... 💀 ☠️ 💀
04:10 user333_ go look at (old)oldstable now
04:19 MTDiscord <warr1024> I generally recommend/use flatpak for all non-dev use on debian.
05:02 technomancy joined #luanti
05:24 Helenah joined #luanti
05:24 Helenah I'm now dynamically adding and removing worlds in-game on the fly. :D
05:56 FeXoR joined #luanti
06:33 pinapelz joined #luanti
07:07 YuGiOhJCJ joined #luanti
07:15 YuGiOhJCJ joined #luanti
07:22 mmww joined #luanti
07:24 YuGiOhJCJ joined #luanti
07:31 BadGuyAlex joined #luanti
07:31 dudz joined #luanti
08:05 YuGiOhJCJ joined #luanti
08:34 Helenah joined #luanti
08:47 Warr1024 joined #luanti
10:10 ___nick___ joined #luanti
10:10 fling joined #luanti
10:11 wisxenia joined #luanti
10:13 ___nick___ joined #luanti
10:26 est31 joined #luanti
10:37 est31 joined #luanti
11:37 calculon joined #luanti
12:00 chripo joined #luanti
12:57 PoochInquisitor joined #luanti
13:14 GNUHacker joined #luanti
14:16 dudz joined #luanti
14:24 PoochInquisitor joined #luanti
14:35 Helenah joined #luanti
15:07 mrkubax10 joined #luanti
17:10 Panquesito7 joined #luanti
17:17 mrkubax10 joined #luanti
17:44 TheWild joined #luanti
18:11 TheWild joined #luanti
18:41 TheWild joined #luanti
20:06 Guest8987 joined #luanti
20:10 Guest8987 joined #luanti
20:18 mrkubax10 joined #luanti
20:18 Guest8987 joined #luanti
20:29 sparky4 joined #luanti
20:32 Guest8987 joined #luanti
20:35 Helenah joined #luanti
21:23 Guest8987 joined #luanti
21:30 Guest8987 joined #luanti
21:30 Guest8987 <SYSTEM> ✔ Minetest started!
21:30 Guest8987 <Sheriff_U1> ❱ Joined the game
21:31 rubenwardy joined #luanti
21:31 Guest8987 <Sheriff_U1> ❰ Left the game
21:31 Guest8987 <SYSTEM> ✖ Minetest shutting down!
21:32 Sheriff_U3 Well at least it worked finally.
21:32 ZenonSeth joined #luanti
21:33 peterz joined #luanti
21:49 [MatrxMT]_ <Blockhead256> ..you bridged your own server to the public room? interesting
21:49 ZenonSeth bald move
21:49 Sheriff_U3 It was a test
21:49 ZenonSeth bold*
21:50 Sheriff_U3 This one was the first one I thought of.
22:10 mrkubax10 joined #luanti
22:15 MTDiscord <wsor4035> you know you can just make any random irc channel right?
22:20 Sheriff_U3 Thought of that afterwards.
22:21 Sheriff_U3 I didn't expect it to send a message for startup or shutdown.
22:22 [MatrxMT]_ <Blockhead256> it's only a few messages, don't sweat
22:31 Sheriff_U3 It was getting too quiet in here anyways
22:33 panwolfram joined #luanti
22:43 sparky4 joined #luanti
23:03 ZenonSet- joined #luanti
23:11 ZenonSeth joined #luanti
23:15 ZenonSeth joined #luanti
23:16 ZenonSeth joined #luanti
23:18 ZenonSeth joined #luanti

| Channels | #luanti index | Today | | Google Search | Plaintext